Holey Holy
Updated: 2 minutes ago

Nick Payne is a respected and much-produced British dramatist with a penchant for fractured storytelling that jumps back and forth in time. His chief interests—judging from the three plays I’ve seen in New York, Constellations (2015), Incognito (2016) and A Life (2019)—are the complexities of identity, self, and memory and the profound ambiguities lurking in alternative-reality tales.
If that sounds esoteric, it is. To backtrack, A Life was uncharacteristically simple: a slender, 45-minute monologue for the star Jake Gyllenhaal juxtaposing a child’s birth and a parent’s death. But Constellations and Incognito, both full-length, used highbrow subjects like string theory and neuropsychology in the manner of Stoppard to create cracked, complicating mirrors for touching stories about love and loss. Both featured very juicy parts for actors, but I nevertheless found their thick intellectual crusts a bit tiresome and their jumpy storytelling labored and repetitious. Now, Payne’s new play The Unbelievers has arrived in New York—cannily directed by Knud Adams at MTC’s City Center—and it has exactly the same merits and demerits.
The Unbelievers (110 minutes long, without intermission) is about the unexplained disappearance of a 15-year-old British boy named Oscar. Its main focus is the suffering of Oscar’s mother Miriam, whose frantic and overbearing behavior and refusal to move on with her life grow more and more unsettling as the play goes on. The action toggles continually between three different time-frames—one right after the disappearance, another a year later, and another seven years later—juggling a variety of tones, speeds, and comic registers. Lauren Ambrose’s extraordinary performance as Miriam is the highlight of the evening, and the other actors are all excellent as well.
When Oscar vanished, Miriam had just separated from her husband David (Tom Riley), and we quickly witness a dispute between them. Miriam wants to plead for help on TV but David demurs, lest their separation raise tricky questions that diminish public sympathy for their cause. Their 17-year-old daughter Margaret (Elizabeth Yeoman) is at first as invested as they are in finding Oscar, yet in time she comes to resent her mother’s all-consuming devotion to the case—questioning, for instance, why she keeps doggedly following up on the most egregiously bogus reported sightings. Margaret moves on, getting pregnant and bringing home her boyfriend Benjamin (Jack DiFalco), whom Miriam treats rudely. David also moves on, bringing over his new partner Lorraine, a perky woman played by the same actor (Marjan Neshat) who plays a perky detective. Miriam is rude to her too.

We also meet Miriam’s first husband Karl (Hadi Tabbal)—a vicar who (apropos of nothing) helpfully reminds us that he’s allowed to have sex—and his and Miriam’s non-binary child Nancy (Nina Ross), who also feels neglected by Miriam and seeks solace in spiritualism and music. Nancy brings Miriam to a séance where the medium (Brittany Bradford) tries to conjure Oscar’s spirit; it doesn’t go well. With Karl’s help, David plans a religious memorial seven years after the disappearance, hoping to find “closure,” but Miriam, touting her atheism, objects and excludes herself.
The title The Unbelievers seems to have something to do with all the character tensions between atheism and religion, and spiritualism and rationalism. To be honest, though, I’m not entirely clear on Payne’s point. His main emotional question is clear: how does a wounded and isolated psyche grieve and heal when its siloed ego and guarded heart keep it from meaningfully reaching out or joining any community? Excellent question, but what “unbelief” has to do with it is decidedly blurry to me. Miriam—captious, brittle, interruptive, insulting—remains so unreachable for most of the play that whatever it is she believes seems barely relevant.
Adams, for his part, has decided to foreground religion. With set designer Paul Steinberg, he has arranged the City Center Stage 1 theater to resemble a church, dividing the stage area in two, with a plain, cream-colored living room for the actors on one side and rows of pews on the other. Audience members watch from the pews, catty-corner to the normal theater seats, and a stained-glass window and arched alcove complete the effect. (A candle in the alcove is lit by Miriam at the start and burns through the whole show.) This is unquestionably a warm and solemn environment, but its warmth can’t possibly compensate for the holes in Payne’s story.

And those holes? They are many and frustrating. The script tells us next to nothing, for instance, about what most of the characters do, or what their beliefs are, or what their lives are like outside the scenes, and there’s little connective tissue between the timelines. The lack of connection and context eventually feels evasive. So many questions press forward. What went wrong in Miriam and David’s marriage? What were their differing values? And did both want to separate? When and why did Karl become a vicar? Why is his faith important to the play? And how did Nancy get interested in music when no one else in the family apparently was? How did "they" progress from music to spiritualism?
These are just a few of the countless holes. I am perfectly aware, mind you, of the obvious artistic point of the play’s fractured storytelling. The careening time frames are meant to disorient us in a manner parallel to Miriam’s rocky mental state. Payne uses the rushing scene shifts to keep us reeling just as Miriam is kept reeling by a world spinning mercilessly forward without ever offering definitive answers about her beloved missing boy. There’s nothing wrong with this formal plan. The one catch in it is that, in practice, it can only be as strong as the tale at its center.
By Nick Payne
Directed by Knud Adams
Manhattan Theatre Club NY City Center Stage 1




Comments